This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Find out more here.  

EU Targets UK Anti-Avoidance Laws

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Unexpected infringement proceedings launched by the European Commission may force the UK to rescind tax rules on assets transferred abroad, and its treatment of the gains of non-UK resident companies, a move that strikes at the very heart of the country's anti-avoidance legislation with regard to offshore asset protection arrangements.

In a reasoned opinion, which requires the UK to respond within two months, the Commission said the provisions were “disproportionate, in the sense they go beyond what is reasonably necessary in order to prevent abuse of tax avoidance.”

The Commission's opinion is based on the fact that, when the rules are applied, domestic investments (in the UK), face lower tax than investments for instance within the EU. The case concerns UK tax law introduced to deter taxpayers from using offshore structures to minimize tax liability, combatted by allowing the tax authority to apply 'look through' taxation of foreign companies' income and capital gains.

David Kilshaw, of KPMG, said the ruling conjured, “a vision of a tidal wave of money moving offshore” if the Revenue were forced to draw the teeth of its anti-avoidance legislation. “This announcement shakes the very foundations of the UK tax system,” he said, adding:

“It is sections 720 and s13 which largely reduce the opportunity for taxpayers to shelter their income and gains from tax by the simple expedient of holding them via an offshore structure. The provisions, where they operate, pierce the veil of the offshore structures and essentially make the profits taxable in the UK.”

“These provisions are a key part of anti-avoidance legislation in the UK and any change could have a profound impact on the structure of UK tax legislation and how individuals operate their businesses and hold their investments,” he surmised.

“The Commission believes discrimination exists as, if the individual had invested assets in a UK company (rather than a company within the EU) the individual would not be subject to tax; only the UK company would be taxed on its income. The Commission’s alert implies that they are only interested in a transfer of assets to a foreign company; however the rules go further than this as they apply to transfers to any foreign persons. It is unclear at the current time whether the action will be taken against the rules in their totality or only on transfers to a non-UK but EU resident company.”

"At present, the UK tax system keeps some balance between incorporated and unincorporated business by allowing for a reduced rate of corporate tax (21%) for smaller profit levels compared to the income tax rate of 50% at its highest. If profits are distributed as dividends further income tax is paid so the overall tax rate on profits can be around the same as for an unincorporated business at between 21 and 50%."

“To extend these anti-avoidance rules to UK companies would add compliance costs for such small companies and accelerate or increase the income tax charge on their owners. This could have a major impact on small business in the UK. It therefore seems more likely that the UK government will look instead to dis-apply the current rules only where EU companies are used for genuine business purposes other than to accumulate income.“

“It is clear that we are entering a period of uncertainty. It is less clear how that uncertainty will be resolved – for example, might the UK government respond to any such challenge by imposing a similar tax charge on certain UK companies? However, this approach, while possibly addressing the Commission’s concern, could have a major effect on a key area of UK tax policy. “

“One thing above all does seem clear however. The landscape as we know it is set to change forever. All taxpayers need to reflect now on how to position themselves for change.”

Andrew Tailby-Faulkes, private client services partner at Ernst & Young, commented that these anti-avoidance rules have been very effective for many years at discouraging UK resident and domiciled taxpayers from sheltering tax by placing their assets in structures overseas. "However," he said "if the UK is forced to accept the changes being recommended by the European Commission then both native tax payers and non-doms would have more opportunity to make use of lower tax countries within the EU to lower their tax burdens."

Tailby-Faulkes also noted that the ruling introduces some "significant complexities which will raise lots of question marks."

"These include, how will overseas trusts be impacted? What is the position if an EU-based company owned by a UK taxpayer in turn has a non-EU subsidiary that holds the investments?," he observed.

“Until the position is clarified, particularly as the government is also expected to make further announcements on tax residence and domicile status imminently, there is unlikely to be a rush by wealthy taxpayers to review their asset-holding arrangements just yet," Tailby-Faulkes said.

Mailing List

Click here to manage your mailing list preferences, or view our privacy statement.

The Report

Offshore Trusts Guide: Introduction

The History of Offshore Trusts
Development of Professional Competence in the Jurisdictions
What Future for the Trust?
The New Age of Transparency
The Swiss Association of Trust Companies
The Society of Trusts and Estates Practitioners

Offshore Trusts Guide: Jurisdictions


Bahamas: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Bahamas: 2006 Private Trust Companies Legislation


Barbados: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Barbados: Supervisory and Licensing Regime and Fees


Bermuda: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Bermuda: Supervisory and Licensing Regime and Fees

British Virgin Islands

British Virgin Islands: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
British Virgin Islands: Special Trusts Act 2003
British Virgin Islands: The Trustee Act 2003
British Virgin Islands: :Supervisory and Licensing Regime and Fees
British Virgin Islands: New Laws on Private Trust Companies
British Virgin Islands: New Private Trust Company Regulations

Cayman Islands

Cayman Islands: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Cayman Islands: Supervisory and Licensing Regime and Fees

Cook Islands

Cook Islands: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Cook Islands: Supervisory and Licensing Regime and Fees


Cyprus: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Cyprus: Supervision, Licensing and Tax


Gibraltar: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Gibraltar: Legislation, Regulation and Supervision


Guernsey: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Guernsey: Trusts Law 2007

Isle of Man

Isle of Man: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Isle of Man: Supervisory and Licensing Regime
Isle of Man: Uses Clients and Tax Treatment


Jersey: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Jersey: Supervisory and Licensing Regime
Jersey: Trusts Amendment Act 2006
Jersey: Foundations


Liechtenstein: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Liechtenstein: Regulation Supervision and Transparency
Liechtenstein: Characteristics of Liechtenstein Trusts
Liechtenstein: Foundations


Madeira: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees


Malta: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Malta: The Trust and Trustees Act 2004


Mauritius: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Mauritius: Characteristics of the 2001 Trusts Act
Mauritius: Additional Provisions of the 2001 Trusts Act
Mauritius: Tax Treatment


Monaco: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees


Nevis: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees


Panama: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Panama: Requirements for Acting as Trust Company in Panama


Seychelles: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees

Turks & Caicos

Turks & Caicos: Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees
Turks & Caicos: The Voidable Dispositions Ordinance


Vanuatu Legal Framework and Formation Rules and Fees

Latest News

Jersey Regulator Issues AML/CTF Funds Guidance
Jersey's financial services regulator, the Jersey Financial Services Commission, has issued new anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism guidance for Funds and Fund Operators.

More Tax Hikes For UK Taxpayers In 2017 Budget
The UK Budget, released on March 9, 2017, featured tax measures to, among other things, hike taxes on self-employed workers, further close avenues for legal avoidance, and defer mandatory digital tax reporting until April 2019.

ACOSS Submits Recommendations For Australian Budget
The Australian Council of Social Services has urged that the Government abolish ineffective tax concessions, introduce a sugary drinks tax, and scrap its company tax proposals.

MEPs Call For Wider Access To Beneficial Ownership Data
EU citizens would be able to view information in registers of beneficial ownership without having to demonstrate a "legitimate interest," under proposed amendments the Anti-Money Laundering Directive.

New Zealand Tax Changes Enter Into Force
A Bill including provisions to simplify New Zealand's tax processes, reduce compliance costs for smaller businesses, and tighten foreign trust disclosure rules received Royal Assent on February 21.

Guernsey Introduces Client Asset Handling Rules
Guernsey's financial services regulator, the Guernsey Financial Services Commission, said it intends to introduce rules governing the holding and administration of client assets in 2017.

Australian Accountants Urge Tax Burden Shift
Australia desperately needs large scale tax reform and should aim to rebalance its tax mix, the Institute of Public Accountants has argued.

IRS Issues Final Regulations On REIT Spin-Offs
On January 18, the US Internal Revenue Service issued its final regulations regarding the measures included in the Protecting Americans from Tax Hikes Act to restrict the tax-free spin-offs involving publicly traded real estate investment trusts (REITs).

Bermuda, EU To Collaborate On Insurance, Pensions Oversight
The European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority and the Bermuda Monetary Authority have newly signed a memorandum of understanding.

Hong Kong Consults On Beneficial Ownership Plans
Hong Kong's Financial Services and the Treasury Bureau has launched public consultations on legislative proposals to increase the transparency of corporate beneficial ownership in the city, and to enhance its regulatory regime for combating money laundering and terrorist financing.

Hong Kong Reports On Incorporations In 2016
There was an increase in local company incorporations in Hong Kong in 2016, although incorporations by foreign companies experienced a dip, according to the territory's Companies Registry.

Guernsey Regulator Outlines 2017 Funds Strategy
Guernsey's financial services regulator, the Guernsey Financial Services Commission, has outlined its funds sector strategy for 2017.

Canada Waives Income, Activities Reporting For Labor Org's
Canada's Revenue Minister has announced that certain reporting requirements on labor organizations and labor trusts will be waived.

South African Tax Bills Approved By Parliament
South Africa's Ministry of Finance has published the 2016 Taxation Laws Amendment Bill, which has received parliamentary approval and gives effect to the tax changes announced in the Budget in February this year, together with legislation confirming the final details of. the Special Voluntary Disclosure Program.

Switzerland Praised For Combatting Financial Crime
The Swiss Federal Council has hailed the publication of the Financial Action Task Force's fourth mutual evaluation report on action taken to combat money laundering and terrorist financing, stating that "overall Switzerland's results can be considered to be good."